CMC Editor’s Intro: Wrong You Are

Most people know the Big Bang created our universe. Unless one believes humankind to be the work of Zeus, Buddha, a Jewish carpenter’s dad, Constantine’s pagan sun god, or Mohammed, you probably put your faith in science.And if you subscribe to science you know there is truth in the Big Bang — the tremendously awesome explosion that created the universe 13.8 billion years ago. Here’s the thing though — you may be wrong. Indeed, science often is.

Working off Einstein’s famous theory of relativity and 1950s-era research from both theoretical physicist David Bohm and physicist Amal Kumar Raychaudhuri, two modern-day scientists may have recently disproved the Big Bang. As with most complex scientific data, the details of this study wrinkled my brain. The hypothesis, however, did seem clear: the giant explosion that started it all may not have happened at all.

Shortly after the paper was published in February 2015, the media did what media often does — they blew it out of proportion with the magnitude of a cosmic explosion. Headlines declared the “Big Bang is Dead,” internet commenters continued their eternal-but-banal god-versus-science debates, and the study enjoyed a brief 15 minutes of fame before pop culture and curated war coverage gained our attention again.

While this shallow reportage occurred, the scientific community did what they have done for millennia — they quietly sharpened their pencils, dug into the archives and double-checked their research. After all, maybe these new dudes had a point? No one could be certain they were correct until it had been peer-reviewed and proven. This is science, after all. It takes a long time to get right. In fact, it takes forever.

Contrary to those who continue to spread the falsity that “science is the new religion,” I maintain that science is not a belief. It is a process. It is a method in which we strip away what is empirically wrong in the search for what is undeniably right. But here’s the rub. As we evolve both in culture and academia, new evidence is unearthed.

What we know as truth changes shape. The truth never changes; only what we perceive as truth. We build on the milestones, and also on the mistakes. We evolve. Most of us, anyway. Science is, in practice, an unending act of humility in the pursuit of truth. It means saying you’re wrong without having to say you’re sorry. It means your peers do not tear you down but, rather, thank you — even when you’ve been incorrect. Imagine if we all lived this way. Being wrong has never been so beautiful.

— Mike Berard, editor

Share your thoughts on this post